Peltola Tops 50% in Alaska as Appeals Court Weighs DOJ Bid to Block Certification

Peltola Tops 50% in Alaska as Appeals Court Weighs DOJ Bid to Block Certification
An election worker sorts ballots under a desk lamp in an Alaska counting room at night, with a courthouse column reflected in the window, illustrating the vote count and certification dispute in the state's U.S. Senate race.

As of Nov. 15, 2026. Alaska’s U.S. Senate race is the last uncalled Senate contest in the country, and it now sits at the intersection of two clocks: a vote count that must finish by Wednesday and a federal appeal that asks a court to stop the result from ever being certified.

Democrat Mary Peltola moved above the 50% threshold in first-choice votes after Saturday’s tally, while Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan trailed by roughly four points. The Alaska Division of Elections plans to keep counting through Nov. 18, the deadline for absentee ballots mailed from overseas, and to run a ranked choice tabulation that day if no candidate holds a majority. State certification is slated for Nov. 25. Meanwhile, the U.S. Department of Justice is pressing a Ninth Circuit appeal of a dismissed lawsuit that sought to block certification of the race — an appeal that election law scholars argue has been overtaken by the numbers.

Facts: where the Alaska count stands

The Division of Elections counted roughly 4,000 additional ballots on Saturday, bringing the statewide total to more than 283,000, according to the Anchorage Daily News. Peltola held 50.1% of first-choice votes to Sullivan’s 46.1%. The Associated Press estimated 97% of the expected vote had been counted as of Saturday and had not called the race, Alaska Public Media reported.

Two other candidates remain on the ballot: Gerald Heikes, a perennial Republican candidate, and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher from Petersburg who shares the incumbent’s name. Neither is close to the leaders.

The uncalled result is not a dispute about which party controls the Senate. Democrats have already won both chambers, and a Peltola victory would give their caucus 56 seats; a Sullivan hold would leave it at 55, Alaska Public Media reported. Peltola would be the first Indigenous Alaskan elected to the Senate.

Separately, the AP called the governor’s race for Democrat Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins on Friday evening. He held 50.9% to Republican Bernadette Wilson’s 28% after Saturday’s count. Alaska voters also rejected Ballot Measure 2, which would have repealed the state’s open primary and ranked choice system, NPR reported.

Facts: the certification calendar

Alaska law and division practice set out a sequence that is now compressed into the next ten days:

  • Nov. 18: Final day to accept absentee ballots mailed from outside the U.S., 15 days after Election Day. The division also conducts the ranked choice tabulation that day if no candidate has cleared 50% of first-choice votes.
  • Nov. 25: Target date for the state’s certification of results, according to Alaska Public Media.
  • January: The new Congress convenes, and the Senate swears in members whose elections it has judged under Article I, Section 5 of the Constitution.

If Peltola’s share stays above 50%, she wins outright and no tabulation is needed. If it slips below, the division eliminates the last-place candidate and reallocates those ballots to voters’ next choices, a process described in detail by NBC News’ decision desk analysis. That analysis found that ballot exhaustion sharply limits how many votes can transfer, and that Sullivan’s path through a tabulation was already effectively closed before Saturday’s count.

Facts: the federal lawsuit and its appeal

The Justice Department sued Alaska on Oct. 22, before the election was over, seeking to block certification of the Senate race if Sullivan lost. The theory rested on the preamble of the National Voter Registration Act and on the claim that voters were confused by two candidates named Dan Sullivan.

U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case on Sunday, Nov. 1. She found the federal government lacked the ability to bring the suit, and that the order it requested would likely violate Alaskans’ right to a secret ballot. “The absence of any explanation from the United States as to how its requested relief could redress its alleged injury while simultaneously maintaining the secrecy of the ballot is telling,” Gleason wrote, according to NPR.

The government filed a notice of appeal, and voting rights groups that intervened in the case — including the League of Women Voters and Common Cause — moved on Nov. 9 to dismiss the appeal, according to the Election Law Blog. On Friday, Nov. 13, two sets of amicus briefs urged the Ninth Circuit to affirm the dismissal quickly: one from former Maricopa County Recorder Stephen Richer, and one from UCLA Law’s Safeguarding Democracy Project, led by election law professor Richard Hasen, Democracy Docket reported.

As of Saturday, the Justice Department had not filed a merits brief in the appeal or sought emergency relief that would pause certification, according to the Election Law Blog. The government did not request an expedited schedule, Alaska Public Media reported, meaning no appellate decision is expected before the new Congress is sworn in.

Analysis: why the appeal is running out of runway

Three things have changed since the lawsuit was filed, and each weakens the government’s position.

First, the factual premise has narrowed. The suit argued that confusion between the two Sullivans could have cost the incumbent the seat, but Peltola’s lead is now larger than the combined vote total of both Sullivans, Alaska Public Media noted. A remedy premised on a decisive diversion of votes has no arithmetic to attach to.

Second, the procedural clock has moved. Laches — the doctrine that bars relief when a plaintiff unreasonably delays and prejudices others — is central to the amicus briefs, which argue the government waited until the last minute to seek an injunction that would disrupt a lawful state count. Courts are generally reluctant to rewrite election procedures after voting has ended.

Third, the legal theory is narrow and contested. The briefs argue that a preamble cannot supply authority for federal supervision of state certification, and that the major questions doctrine and the Tenth Amendment cut against the government’s reading. Those arguments are not novel; they mirror reasoning courts have used in other 2026 election disputes, including the fight over the Postal Service’s mail-ballot rule that twelve states are still appealing.

None of this guarantees an outcome. The Ninth Circuit could still rule on the merits, and a ruling would matter beyond Alaska as a statement about how far the executive branch can reach into state certification. But an appellate decision that lands after a state has certified — and after the Senate has seated a winner — would have little practical effect.

Facts and analysis: what the investigations do and do not change

A separate track involves the recruitment of Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. A New York Times report on Democratic operatives’ efforts to recruit him drew attention to long-running spoiler allegations, which Peltola has denied. U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman has said a criminal investigation is ongoing, and Gov. Mike Dunleavy has opened a state inquiry, NPR reported.

Those investigations are not, by themselves, a legal obstacle to certification. Alaska Public Media reported that no apparent legal bar stands in the way of the state’s Nov. 25 certification. Sullivan said in a CNN interview before the election that he would accept the results win or lose, according to NPR. Election officials have announced no change to the count.

What to watch this week

Counting continues into next week and runs through Wednesday. Watch three markers: whether Peltola stays above 50% of first-choice votes, whether the division proceeds with the Nov. 18 tabulation, and whether the Ninth Circuit acts on the pending motions before Nov. 25. The state’s certification, not a race call, is the step that makes the result official — a distinction that has shaped every close contest this cycle, from Mississippi’s Senate count to the uncalled Alaska race itself.

Sources

Advertisement

Filed under:

Keep reading