Senate Proposal to End China’s Trade Status Puts Tariffs and Prices Back in Focus

Senate Proposal to End China’s Trade Status Puts Tariffs and Prices Back in Focus
Editorial illustration of the U.S. Capitol, shipping containers and tariff documents representing a Senate proposal to change China’s trade status.

Sen. Tammy Baldwin, D-Wis., introduced a bill Tuesday that would revoke China’s permanent normal trade relations status, a move that would place Chinese imports under higher tariff rates after a one-year transition. The proposal arrives just before President Donald Trump is expected to meet Chinese President Xi Jinping, and it reopens a long-running argument over whether tougher trade rules would protect U.S. industry or raise costs for American households and businesses.

The measure is new, but it is not yet a change in policy. It has been introduced in the Senate and would still need to pass both chambers and receive the president’s signature. Its prospects are also uncertain because the next Congress will have to organize around the post-midterm election balance of power. Reuters reported that Democrats won control of both chambers in the November elections, but that does not by itself establish support for this bill or guarantee a vote.

What the bill would change

Facts: China has had permanent normal trade relations, or PNTR, with the United States since 2002. PNTR generally places Chinese goods on the ordinary “Column 1” tariff schedule used for countries receiving normal trade treatment. Baldwin’s official release says the bill, called the Ending China’s Special Treatment Act, would revoke that status one year after enactment and move Chinese imports to the higher “Column 2” rates in the Harmonized Tariff Schedule.

The bill would also direct the U.S. Trade Representative to prepare a report, in consultation with the International Trade Commission, the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission and the Commerce Department, on continuing trade and economic challenges posed by China. The proposal is framed as a statutory framework intended to make China policy less dependent on changing executive actions.

Baldwin said the United States had “rolled out the red carpet for China” while Beijing engaged in market manipulation, intellectual-property theft and industrial policies that harmed U.S. workers. Her office argues that a durable tariff framework would put American workers and manufacturers first. Those are the sponsor’s policy arguments, not findings that Congress or a court has adopted.

Analysis: PNTR revocation would not automatically erase every existing China tariff. It would change the baseline tariff treatment for Chinese goods, while other duties and trade restrictions could continue to apply separately. The practical effect would vary widely by product because Column 2 rates differ across the tariff schedule. A one-year delay after enactment would give importers time to adjust, but it would not eliminate the risk of higher landed costs.

The economic trade-off is measurable but uncertain

Facts: The USITC examined the consequences of revoking PNTR in an August 2026 report. In its model of an immediate and complete shift of all Chinese goods from Column 1 to Column 2 rates, the agency estimated that U.S. consumer prices would be about 0.8% higher in the first year and 1.0% higher in the sixth year relative to its 2023 baseline. U.S. real output would be 0.3% lower in the sixth year, while imports from China would fall 30.8%.

The same model projected that U.S. buyers would replace some Chinese goods with domestic production and imports from other suppliers, including Mexico, Taiwan and Vietnam. Domestic producers’ total shipments would rise 0.5% in the sixth year, but higher input costs would weigh on output and exports. The report’s long-run estimate was smaller than the sixth-year price effect: consumer prices would be 0.7% above the baseline after the economy fully adjusted.

The USITC describes these results as model estimates, not a forecast of what will happen under every possible bill. Its analysis isolates the tariff change and uses 2023 as the baseline, so it does not incorporate every other tariff, supply-chain shift, exchange-rate movement or future trade agreement. The commission also examined a separate five-year phase-in for a subset of national-security products. That scenario is not necessarily the structure in Baldwin’s proposal.

Analysis: The numbers illustrate the central policy conflict. A higher tariff wall could reduce reliance on Chinese suppliers and give some U.S. producers more room to compete. It could also raise the cost of imported consumer goods and intermediate inputs used by American manufacturers. Whether domestic production expands enough to offset those costs would depend on investment, labor availability, alternative suppliers and the response from China.

The proposal therefore carries different risks for different groups. Companies that can shift sourcing or compete directly with Chinese imports may see strategic benefits. Retailers, manufacturers that depend on Chinese components and consumers buying affected goods could face higher prices. The bill’s effect on inflation would also depend on how quickly firms pass costs through and how much trade moves to other countries.

Why the timing matters for U.S.-China policy

Facts: The bill was introduced days before a planned Trump-Xi meeting at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit. Reuters reported that the current U.S.-China tariff truce is expected to expire in January and that the leaders are expected to discuss trade tensions. The Congressional Research Service says China remains a major source of U.S. consumer goods and manufacturing inputs, while U.S. officials continue to cite Chinese trade barriers, industrial policy, export controls and intellectual-property concerns.

Congress has debated revoking China’s special tariff treatment before. The CRS notes that earlier bills, including H.R. 694 and S. 206, would also revoke PNTR treatment. The USITC’s investigation notice explains that Congress asked for an analysis of the economic and sourcing effects, but the commission itself makes no policy recommendation.

Analysis: The immediate political effect may be greater than the immediate economic effect because the bill is unlikely to alter tariffs unless it becomes law. It gives Democrats a way to press a worker-focused China message while challenging the administration’s reliance on executive tariff actions. It also forces lawmakers to confront a difficult question: whether a more predictable, congressionally enacted tariff regime is preferable to fluctuating executive measures if the predictable regime imposes broader costs.

For now, the proposal is best understood as a signal, not a completed policy. Its next meaningful tests would be referral to a Senate committee, the emergence of bipartisan cosponsors, and whether negotiators attach its provisions to a larger trade or national-security measure. None of those steps is guaranteed.

As of November 18, 2026.

China’s PNTR status remains in place, Baldwin’s bill has been introduced but not enacted, and the USITC’s price and output figures remain counterfactual estimates rather than observed effects.

Sources

Advertisement

Filed under:

Keep reading